Search found 83 matches
- Fri Jan 13, 2017 4:43 pm
- Forum: Samatha Bhāvana
- Topic: Samatha and Anatta
- Replies: 47
- Views: 13948
Re: Samatha and Anatta
What is your opinion on why Buddha, his teachers and his ascetic friends did not achieve even stream entry despite achieving all 8 jhanas ? What is your opinion on all people that ever achieved stream entry in the suttas did so after hearing a discourse, while there are zero cases where they did it...
- Fri Jan 13, 2017 2:22 pm
- Forum: Samatha Bhāvana
- Topic: Samatha and Anatta
- Replies: 47
- Views: 13948
Re: Samatha and Anatta
But it is later, not sooner. Right concentration (witch means jhana) is the 8th step of the noble 8thfold path. It is closely connected with non-returning. What a person first has to do is the first step of the path: right view (stream entry). I have no idea where you get that from but if it's work...
- Fri Jan 13, 2017 10:16 am
- Forum: Samatha Bhāvana
- Topic: Samatha and Anatta
- Replies: 47
- Views: 13948
Re: Samatha and Anatta
Please feel free to correct it. Realization about non existence of a self is done through contemplating suttas dealing with dependent origination, such as most suttas from SN. It is important to pay special attention to those suttas that end up with "after hearing this discourses, 20 bhikkhus ...
- Thu Jan 12, 2017 5:37 pm
- Forum: Samatha Bhāvana
- Topic: Samatha and Anatta
- Replies: 47
- Views: 13948
Re: Samatha and Anatta
Please feel free to correct it.Twilight wrote:I don't know where you got these strange ideas from. Certainly not from the suttas.srivijaya wrote:
Stress equates to "self" - that's all "self" amounts to, nothing else.
Dissolving stress = dissolving "self" = anatta.
- Thu Jan 12, 2017 4:02 pm
- Forum: Samatha Bhāvana
- Topic: Samatha and Anatta
- Replies: 47
- Views: 13948
Re: Samatha and Anatta
There are two components to meditation; calmness and awareness. The calmer you become, the more awareness is able to go deeper. When awareness goes deeper, you are able to locate subtle stress, which is released, leading to deeper calmness. The two are part of the self-same process. Stress equates t...
- Wed Jan 11, 2017 10:15 pm
- Forum: Connections to Other Paths
- Topic: Theravāda & Nāgārjuna
- Replies: 236
- Views: 41898
Re: Theravāda & Nāgārjuna
But how far can an atom of earth element be broken down until it ceases without remainder? Not saying it's your view but I encountered a similar one many years ago whilst studying the tenet systems. It reminds me of the Vaibhasika school. One which accepts truly existent external objects. The basis...
- Tue Jan 03, 2017 12:49 pm
- Forum: General Theravāda discussion
- Topic: Did Buddha say Anihilationism was to be the best of the wrong views.?
- Replies: 30
- Views: 6895
Re: Did Buddha say Anihilationism was to be the best of the wrong views.?
Bhikkhu Bodhi's note 734: MA identifies the three views here as eternalism, annihilationism, and partial eternalism. Those segments didn't suggest that to me at all. I could find neither eternalist nor nihilist views amongst them? I think it is a mistake to assume that Buddha said Anihilationism to...
- Wed Dec 28, 2016 8:16 pm
- Forum: Connections to Other Paths
- Topic: Soul theories and the Dhamma
- Replies: 879
- Views: 304860
Re: Soul theories and the Dhamma
Thats why I suggested that the English word "identity" is closer to the Buddhist conception of "attā" than "self". The equivalent of the English term "self" is "mindstream" in Buddhist terminology, that is just my opinion though. Denying the mindstr...
- Wed Dec 28, 2016 8:13 pm
- Forum: Connections to Other Paths
- Topic: Soul theories and the Dhamma
- Replies: 879
- Views: 304860
Re: Soul theories and the Dhamma
Here's the translation In this body are hairs, down, nails, teeth, skin, flesh, sinews, bone, marrow, kidney, heart, liver, membrane, spleen, lungs, bowels, mesentery, stomach, faeces, bile, phlegm, pus, blood, sweat, fat, tears, saliva, snot, synovial fluid, urine, and goes on to meditate after th...
- Wed Dec 28, 2016 7:25 pm
- Forum: Connections to Other Paths
- Topic: Soul theories and the Dhamma
- Replies: 879
- Views: 304860
Re: Soul theories and the Dhamma
A postulated "eternal, unchanging" soul is a conceptually fabricated straw-man. Because a self by very definition is a living thing and must change [in some sense at least]. Nor are unchanging and eternal equivalent words [at least not in all senses]. Very much so. Once the conceptually f...
- Sun Dec 25, 2016 8:27 am
- Forum: Connections to Other Paths
- Topic: Soul theories and the Dhamma
- Replies: 879
- Views: 304860
Re: Soul theories and the Dhamma
A postulated "eternal, unchanging" soul is a conceptually fabricated straw-man. The refutation predicated on this 'assertion' has as much "substance" as 'the child of a barren woman'. Self/No-self assertion and denial are meaningless obscurations.
- Fri Dec 23, 2016 10:06 am
- Forum: Classical Theravāda
- Topic: Book about Anattā - No Inner Core
- Replies: 24
- Views: 8478
Re: Book about Anattā - No Inner Core
The linked suttas do not appear to contain speculative doctrinal expositions on the existence/non-existence of atta. If they do, then please make it more explicit. I would like to see why you consider they do. You may be forgetting what you were claiming as speculation. This is your post I responde...
- Fri Dec 23, 2016 10:03 am
- Forum: Classical Theravāda
- Topic: Book about Anattā - No Inner Core
- Replies: 24
- Views: 8478
Re: Book about Anattā - No Inner Core
I think you are confusing metaphysical existence, ontological existence, and phenomenological existence. Hi Coëmgenu, Interesting observation. Not something I think I'm doing but I'll defer to your judgement on that. from a phenomenological angle, the Buddha does thoroughly dismiss selfhood, notion...
- Thu Dec 22, 2016 9:55 am
- Forum: Classical Theravāda
- Topic: Book about Anattā - No Inner Core
- Replies: 24
- Views: 8478
Re: Book about Anattā - No Inner Core
Carefully read The Simile of the Snake ( Alagaddūpama Sutta MN.22 ). There are oodles more examples, but this one is the most direct. The linked suttas do not appear to contain speculative doctrinal expositions on the existence/non-existence of atta. If they do, then please make it more explicit. I...
- Wed Dec 21, 2016 3:03 pm
- Forum: Connections to Other Paths
- Topic: Sex positive movement
- Replies: 84
- Views: 17943
Re: Sex positive movement
Even if such a thing were in line with the Buddha's teaching, the act of determining whether or not various worldly conceivings are in line with the Buddha's teaching seems not to be in line with the Buddha's teaching. I could be wrong. Agree. In the group I occasionally attend there is a lady who ...