I have a question regarding gaining insight knowledge. My question is this: Does gaining an insight knowledge cause mental shock? What I mean by mental shock is flash in consciousness. For an example when you have this train of thought: Reality is an illusion. Then your mind is shocked and it produces a flash in consciousness.. Of course I consider reality real. But before when I thought that it is an illusion, I experienced such sensation when I had such a train of thought and was convinced of such belief. Thank you in advance for your answers.
With metta -smokey
Does gaining an insight knowledge cause mental shock?
Re: Does gaining an insight knowledge cause mental shock?
I believe that, sometimes, for a moment there is some excitement when something is known.
But I also believe that the development of equanimity tends to make this moments less intense.
But I also believe that the development of equanimity tends to make this moments less intense.
With Metta
Re: Does gaining an insight knowledge cause mental shock?
smokey wrote:I have a question regarding gaining insight knowledge. My question is this: Does gaining an insight knowledge cause mental shock? What I mean by mental shock is flash in consciousness. For an example when you have this train of thought: Reality is an illusion. Then your mind is shocked and it produces a flash in consciousness.. Of course I consider reality real. But before when I thought that it is an illusion, I experienced such sensation when I had such a train of thought and was convinced of such belief. Thank you in advance for your answers.
Just for background, there is a phenomenon, fairly well established in psychological and religious writing, called a photistic experience. I just tried Googling it but resources are pretty thin.
Consider the stories told by people who encounter aliens: some mention standing in a brilliant white light.
When people encounter angels, again the brilliant white light and perhaps choirs are heard.
Notice in the Zen that a lightning metaphor is often used.
Basically, the mind can and does produce these things. Whether or not they are real I leave to you.
Re: Does gaining an insight knowledge cause mental shock?
Hi Catmoon,
This is getting a little off topic, but the photistic thing you mention sounds like meditation nimittas ("signs") which can appear to be visual (or other) experiences.
I thought Smokey was talking more about a sense of disorientation and "wow" than that sort of thing.
Mike
This is getting a little off topic, but the photistic thing you mention sounds like meditation nimittas ("signs") which can appear to be visual (or other) experiences.
I thought Smokey was talking more about a sense of disorientation and "wow" than that sort of thing.
Mike
Re: Does gaining an insight knowledge cause mental shock?
Well a nimitta is a kind of eidetic image, so I'm not sure if that would be the same. What I've heard sounds more like looking at a radiant object than being immersed in radiant light, but I know very little about it.mikenz66 wrote:Hi Catmoon,
This is getting a little off topic, but the photistic thing you mention sounds like meditation nimittas ("signs") which can appear to be visual (or other) experiences.
I thought Smokey was talking more about a sense of disorientation and "wow" than that sort of thing.
Mike
All I'm saying is that mind can put on a spectacular light show.
Re: Does gaining an insight knowledge cause mental shock?
Little about nimittas or photistic objects?catmoon wrote: Well a nimitta is a kind of eidetic image, so I'm not sure if that would be the same. What I've heard sounds more like looking at a radiant object than being immersed in radiant light, but I know very little about it.
Yes, that's certainly true, and most of it is just noise as far as I can tell. At least for me...catmoon wrote: All I'm saying is that mind can put on a spectacular light show.
Mike
Re: Does gaining an insight knowledge cause mental shock?
Mental shock is not a visual experience and thus you do not see anything, it is a metaphorical flash, flash in consciousness. Such an experience occurs when one has train of thought in mental activity that is very surprising. For an example when one thinks of a reality on a way that he has never thought before. But perhaps such an experience only occurs because of thinking and not of gaining insight knowledge.
Re: Does gaining an insight knowledge cause mental shock?
Well mental shock is probably real. I know that I have experienced very sudden, almost wrenching shifts in consciousness while meditating. Sometimes its like a sudden jump in awareness and alertness. These things happen. I just note them and continue.smokey wrote:Mental shock is not a visual experience and thus you do not see anything, it is a metaphorical flash, flash in consciousness. Such an experience occurs when one has train of thought in mental activity that is very surprising. For an example when one thinks of a reality on a way that he has never thought before. But perhaps such an experience only occurs because of thinking and not of gaining insight knowledge.
Re: Does gaining an insight knowledge cause mental shock?
I think I understand what you are getting at, smokey.smokey wrote:Mental shock is not a visual experience and thus you do not see anything, it is a metaphorical flash, flash in consciousness. Such an experience occurs when one has train of thought in mental activity that is very surprising. For an example when one thinks of a reality [in] a way that he has never thought before. But perhaps such an experience only occurs because of thinking and not of gaining insight knowledge.
It's kind of like when one has the first initial sudden realization about anatta and the process involved with the six sense spheres. When one sees that what is seen is not self, what it heard is not self, what is smelled, tasted, touched, or cognized is not self, this experience can come in a sudden rush of realization, because this was not how one had been previously conditioned to view reality. This "rush of realization," I presume, is what you are referring to as "mental shock." It is usually a one-time event, taking place during the moment when the realization is being made. This event remains in one's memory, but is never really repeated in quite the same way in the future, because the "shock" of the event has worn off. But the memory of having been "shocked out of our old habits of viewing reality" remains. Yes. Such an experience is quite real.
Does that answer your question?
"The gift of truth exceeds all other gifts" — Dhammapada, v. 354 Craving XXIV
Re: Does gaining an insight knowledge cause mental shock?
I suppose it does answer my question. Thank you.IanAnd wrote:I think I understand what you are getting at, smokey.smokey wrote:Mental shock is not a visual experience and thus you do not see anything, it is a metaphorical flash, flash in consciousness. Such an experience occurs when one has train of thought in mental activity that is very surprising. For an example when one thinks of a reality [in] a way that he has never thought before. But perhaps such an experience only occurs because of thinking and not of gaining insight knowledge.
It's kind of like when one has the first initial sudden realization about anatta and the process involved with the six sense spheres. When one sees that what is seen is not self, what it heard is not self, what is smelled, tasted, touched, or cognized is not self, this experience can come in a sudden rush of realization, because this was not how one had been previously conditioned to view reality. This "rush of realization," I presume, is what you are referring to as "mental shock." It is usually a one-time event, taking place during the moment when the realization is being made. This event remains in one's memory, but is never really repeated in quite the same way in the future, because the "shock" of the event has worn off. But the memory of having been "shocked out of our old habits of viewing reality" remains. Yes. Such an experience is quite real.
Does that answer your question?
Re: Does gaining an insight knowledge cause mental shock?
That is also how I took it.mikenz66 wrote:
I thought Smokey was talking more about a sense of disorientation and "wow" than that sort of thing.
Mike
Smokey, I had moments of insights rushing in suddenly that left me quite ...disorientated perhaps.
I needed to be alone and withdraw.
I was fine though. Just didn't want to stop it through dealing with external influences.
-
- Posts: 1614
- Joined: Wed Jul 29, 2009 9:21 am
- Location: By the River Thames near London.
Re: Does gaining an insight knowledge cause mental shock?
People experience the results of meditation in various ways according to a number of factors. There is no right way, only the way that it will take for you. There are commonalities, but also differences. A teacher is a great help in sorting things out. Pointing out the way forward, making suggestions to enhance progress sorting out the difference at times between insight and the arising of psychological disturbances due to sankharas.
The going for refuge is the door of entrance to the teachings of the Buddha.
Bhikku Bodhi.
Bhikku Bodhi.
Re: Does gaining an insight knowledge cause mental shock?
Dear Annabel, can you tell me what insight knowledges have you gained?Annabel wrote:That is also how I took it.mikenz66 wrote:
I thought Smokey was talking more about a sense of disorientation and "wow" than that sort of thing.
Mike
Smokey, I had moments of insights rushing in suddenly that left me quite ...disorientated perhaps.
I needed to be alone and withdraw.
I was fine though. Just didn't want to stop it through dealing with external influences.
With Metta and Karuna -smokey
Re: Does gaining an insight knowledge cause mental shock?
Hi Smokey
Ultimately, the experience of naana is no different to any other experience. They are impermanent, they become a source of dukkha if one develops attachment to them, and they're anatta - not self.
kind regards
Ben
I think we have to be careful to remain equanimous and remain aware of whatever is going on and not to develop craving towards this or that experience or to ascribe meaning to this or that experience. Whatever you experience is just the interplay of dhatu, elements.smokey wrote:Does gaining an insight knowledge cause mental shock? What I mean by mental shock is flash in consciousness. For an example when you have this train of thought: Reality is an illusion. Then your mind is shocked and it produces a flash in consciousness.. Of course I consider reality real. But before when I thought that it is an illusion, I experienced such sensation when I had such a train of thought and was convinced of such belief. Thank you in advance for your answers.
Ultimately, the experience of naana is no different to any other experience. They are impermanent, they become a source of dukkha if one develops attachment to them, and they're anatta - not self.
kind regards
Ben
“No lists of things to be done. The day providential to itself. The hour. There is no later. This is later. All things of grace and beauty such that one holds them to one's heart have a common provenance in pain. Their birth in grief and ashes.”
- Cormac McCarthy, The Road
Learn this from the waters:
in mountain clefts and chasms,
loud gush the streamlets,
but great rivers flow silently.
- Sutta Nipata 3.725
Compassionate Hands Foundation (Buddhist aid in Myanmar) • Buddhist Global Relief • UNHCR
e: [email protected]..
- Cormac McCarthy, The Road
Learn this from the waters:
in mountain clefts and chasms,
loud gush the streamlets,
but great rivers flow silently.
- Sutta Nipata 3.725
Compassionate Hands Foundation (Buddhist aid in Myanmar) • Buddhist Global Relief • UNHCR
e: [email protected]..
- pink_trike
- Posts: 1130
- Joined: Wed Dec 31, 2008 7:29 am
- Contact:
Re: Does gaining an insight knowledge cause mental shock?
Yes, there can be a period of shock as insight reorders perception/senses...sometimes this reordering can even be blissful or disorienting. On occasion, it can be experienced as if a flash of light in the dark, or a gradual sense of more light (less dark), or like a light bulb going on suddenly. There can also be tingling in the body -as if an electrical shock. The body/mind has a sophisticated electrical system that sometimes goes nova as an insight-triggered aha! dharma (with a little "d") explodes into appearance. As Ben points out...best to just note these appearances and experiences and not be enchanted by them. Just more fireworks and potential for distraction and dissatisfaction.
Vision is Mind
Mind is Empty
Emptiness is Clear Light
Clear Light is Union
Union is Great Bliss
- Dawa Gyaltsen
---
Disclaimer: I'm a non-religious practitioner of Theravada, Mahayana/Vajrayana, and Tibetan Bon Dzogchen mind-training.
Mind is Empty
Emptiness is Clear Light
Clear Light is Union
Union is Great Bliss
- Dawa Gyaltsen
---
Disclaimer: I'm a non-religious practitioner of Theravada, Mahayana/Vajrayana, and Tibetan Bon Dzogchen mind-training.