Now you're confused.JoanOfArc wrote:Dearest faithful,
In my past life, I was Helen of Troy.
Joan of Arc.
Now you're confused.JoanOfArc wrote:Dearest faithful,
In my past life, I was Helen of Troy.
.... while you're remembering that, you're not worried about the dhamma.Naga wrote:That would be horrible--to remember causing the deaths of so many other creatures in the grip of your own jaws.notself wrote:
It would be so cool if someone would remember being a lion or tiger or bear. Oh my!
Yes, that's my guess too...Paññāsikhara wrote:My guess would be, that the way the mind works, it is more likely to remember / recall phenomena that are similar to the present conditions.notself wrote:I wonder why no one remembers past lives that are not related to the history that is part of their local culture. For example why does no one from Northern European decent ever remember being a child or adult from Africa or the Arctic area such as Siberia? There is nothing in the suttas that suggests that one is reborn only within a specific geographic area.
eg. when in the living room of your parents house, you will be more likely to recall events that have happened in that living room, or that house. You will be less likely to recall events from another house.
Likewise for recollections as a human, as opposed to some other form.
Highly interesting, yes.And, by the way, reading through various data about recalled past lives, there are plenty of people recalling lives from other places. See Edgar Casey, for instance.
Like I said, there is nothing special about being a slave/serf in a land where slaves/serfs were very prolific, were 10 to the penny. Even less spectacular is a young lad who I associated with a blacksmith (not even saying he was a blacksmith). Perhaps pig herder or turnip polisher would have sufficed? If you are relating to exotic magical mythical and mysterious Greece - that's just your opinion. For me it would be just as meaningful if it was Peckham on a rainy afternoon.pink_trike wrote: Medieval. Blacksmith. Ancient Greece. Marble rooms. Serfs. Slaves. Not so different from Kings. Queens. Handmaidens. Knights. American Indian. India. Egypt. Ireland, Sumer, Mu.
My impressions more than the images came across as totally mundane, totally.pink_trike wrote: I wouldn't be able to count the number of times I've heard these themes over the decades. I was just pointing out that it must be extremely rare for someone to remember dull previous lives that took place in the past 100 years under the most ordinary and mundane circumstances.
Eloquently put. And I wonder if if a poor Mexican farmer living in abject poverty in a rural Mexican town back in 1751 would consider serfdom/slavery exotic?pink_trike wrote: I wonder if a poor Mexican farmer living in abject poverty in a rural Mexican town back in 1751 had memories of being a pretty greek slave girl in a sunlight marble room, having never heard of Greece or marble. Our minds are stuffed with information dust bunnies...every scrap of media we've been exposed to during our entire life is lurking in the depths of mind waiting to be thrown back up in a wave of mental vomit.
If one has a "real" experience of rebirth (whatever that might be), the issue is not some worrying about buying potatoes. It is, rather, an experience that likely puts some flesh on the bones of the Buddha's teachings for that person. If you do not have such an experience, there is no reason that you need to worry about it at all. Also, there is no reason to try to discredit such experiences for those that might have such an experience.Aloka wrote:.
....but is it all relevent when I go to the supermarket to buy a bag of potatoes?.....or should I be wondering if I was an Irish potato picker in a past life ? ....or if I'll be able to get oven-ready chips in a future one ?
tiltbillings wrote:If one has a "real" experience of rebirth (whatever that might be), the issue is not some worrying about buying potatoes. It is, rather, an experience that likely puts some flesh on the bones of the Buddha's teachings for that person. If you do not have such an experience, there is no reason that you need to worry about it at all. Also, there is no reason to try to discredit such experiences for those that might have such an experience. The experience might be something that is a production of the mind or it might be the real thing. Either way, it could be a basis of motivation for practice, and either way, it is not something one needs to hang onto.Aloka wrote:.
....but is it all relevent when I go to the supermarket to buy a bag of potatoes?.....or should I be wondering if I was an Irish potato picker in a past life ? ....or if I'll be able to get oven-ready chips in a future one ?
I did not say you were. I am speaking in general terms.Aloka wrote:tiltbillings wrote:If one has a "real" experience of rebirth (whatever that might be), the issue is not some worrying about buying potatoes. It is, rather, an experience that likely puts some flesh on the bones of the Buddha's teachings for that person. If you do not have such an experience, there is no reason that you need to worry about it at all. Also, there is no reason to try to discredit such experiences for those that might have such an experience.Aloka wrote:.
....but is it all relevent when I go to the supermarket to buy a bag of potatoes?.....or should I be wondering if I was an Irish potato picker in a past life ? ....or if I'll be able to get oven-ready chips in a future one ?
The experience might be something that is a production of the mind or it might be the real thing. Either way, it could be a basis of motivation for practice, and either way, it is not something one needs to hang onto.
Was I trying to discredit anyone, Tiltbillings? Please show me where I did this.
You make good points, such as TV.pink_trike wrote:Perhaps. But we have no way of knowing. Why build stories about them? These memories could very well be preverbal mental constructions serving any number of purposes or no purposes at all. All memories are slippery - I base this opinion partly on having witnessed psychotherapy clients endlessly and sincerely tell different versions of memories at different times in the psychotherapeutic process, and having seem intelligent, sane clients realize that things they clearly "remembered" actually never took place. No point in speculating whether mental constructions that play out in the theater of "before this life" are reflections of actual "past lives" or not, or using them to prop up a faith-determined belief. Imo, we do best to note them and let em go...they're just more fireworks in the present mind stream. That's not to say that these mental constructions that are taking place in the moment of now can't be useful...they can sometimes be reflective of all kinds of mental/emotional patterns taking place in this life that we aren't conscious of...they may reflect our shadow territory, things we don't know about how we are operating in the world. Being aware of these mental constructions that are forming and arising in the present can beneficially cast light on this life.tiltbillings wrote:Sure; on the other hand, it is not out of the realm of possibilities that the mind stream may also, in some cases, deliver what very well may be actual "memories" of a past life.
Medieval. Blacksmith. Ancient Greece. Marble rooms. Serfs. Slaves. Not so different from Kings. Queens. Handmaidens. Knights. American Indian. India. Egypt. Ireland, Sumer, Mu. I wouldn't be able to count the number of times I've heard these themes over the decades. I was just pointing out that it must be extremely rare for someone to remember dull previous lives that took place in the past 100 years under the most ordinary and mundane circumstances. Uruguay? Toronto? Cleveland, Ohio? Pitcairn Islands? Oddly, I've never heard a single past life memory that took place in these places. Mail clerk in Ludlow, Texas - 1963? nope. Garbage collector - Bemidji, Minnesota - 1957? nope. Waiter in San Francisco, 1976? nope. I've never heard anyone speak of these dull kinds of lives - even here in California where the discussion of past lives is as common as discussion of the weather.tiltbillings wrote:Always? Not in the OP accounting and certainly not many other accountings.
It leads me to wonder what kind of "past lives" people "remembered" before television, history books, historical novels, romance novels, films, and all media forms flooded our lives, and before they were taken for granted? I wonder if a poor Mexican farmer living in abject poverty in a rural Mexican town back in 1751 had memories of being a pretty greek slave girl in a sunlight marble room, having never heard of Greece or marble. Our minds are stuffed with information dust bunnies...every scrap of media we've been exposed to during our entire life is lurking in the depths of mind waiting to be thrown back up in a wave of mental vomit. This inundation of imagery and stories that dominates life needs to be included when making considerations about what these types of appearances might actually represent, if they represent anything at all.
Yes, I think there might also be some sort of pressure to report something exotic which catches the eye in an area such as yours, with it's Hollywood bling bling...right?I've never heard anyone speak of these dull kinds of lives - even here in California where the discussion of past lives is as common as discussion of the weather.
Aloka-to me it was relevant to be without fear and repulsion of water.Aloka wrote:.
....but is it all relevent when I go to the supermarket to buy a bag of potatoes?.....or should I be wondering if I was an Irish potato picker in a past life ? ....or if I'll be able to get oven-ready chips in a future one ?
.
.
Thank goodness for that, Mr Tiltbillings !I did not say you were. I am speaking in general terms.
Just tilt, please.Aloka wrote:Thank goodness for that, Mr Tiltbillings !I did not say you were. I am speaking in general terms.
Just got back from taking the beast walkies in the waning (maybe 3/4) moon. It now about 0430 AM here.I hope you are having a lovely bright sunny day wherever you are
Food of the gods.just like I'm having here as I go out to buy my potatoes.
And to you.Kind regards,