Dhammanando wrote:Hi Dhammakid,
Dhammakid wrote:Thank you noble sirs. I am very interested in learning to speak and read Pali fluently, and these dictionaries are a great start for a newbie like me. I do understand, however, that learning fluent Pali is an undertaking mostly likely not fit for an inexperienced lay person such as myself.
Am I right?
I think it would take a lot of work, for rather scant rewards. Who would you want to talk to in Pali? Even among monks the language is usually only learned for the sake of reading and translating texts, and there aren't many who can actually speak it. Generally it's only used when two monks meet and Pali is their only shared language (e.g. when the Burmese monk U Pandita went to visit the Thai abbot of Wat Boworniwet some years ago, or when I once had to look after some elderly monolingual Sinhalese monks).
Or are there opportunities in the States allowing one to learn fluent Pali?
I don't know about the States. In England I've heard that this is something that Prof. Gombrich expected of his students, but he's retired now.
Best wishes,
Dhammanando Bhikkhu
Hello Ajahn,
There are
some who are able to converse in Pali if the necessity arises.
Michael Aris who was an explorer and writer on Tibet and the Himalayas, and also, before his untimely death at the age of 53 years, was the husband of the Burmese political prisoner Daw Aung San Suu Kyi, was just such a one who could speak Pali.
The last time he was in Burma (well before his final illness), he was shadowed by english/burmese speaking intelligence officers. It was only in the presence of Pali speaking Sayadaws that they were able to converse in private in the Pali language with the puzzled I.O.'s looking blank.
He was never allowed back again, with the result that Daw Aung San Suu Kyi wasn't able to comfort him or say good-bye when he was dying of cancer.
metta
Chris