I dont think so Anna dear...
But it would grow again...
Reasons why you do not want to have kids?
Re: Reasons why you do not want to have kids?
1)They take away time, energy, and resources which can be used more effectively in pursuit of a higher goal.
2) They are not "yours" anyway. And even if they were, what bigger ego trip is there than making little people who are just like you?
2) They are not "yours" anyway. And even if they were, what bigger ego trip is there than making little people who are just like you?
Re: Reasons why you do not want to have kids?
Just curious - what are people's opinions on adoption? More altruistic or just as selfish?
-M
-M
Re: Reasons why you do not want to have kids?
Sustaining society is sustaining samsara. If one's focus is sustaining samsara, how does one escape from it?TMingyur wrote:To sustain society and its welfare - just to mention an example aspect of focusing on others in the context of one's own life.
Re: Reasons why you do not want to have kids?
I think there is a greater possibility for altruism in adoption, as it is meeting a need that already exists, as opposed to creating more needs and bringing forth more sufferring. But adoption isn't necessarily altruistic, it depends on the adoptive parents intent and motivation.meindzai wrote:Just curious - what are people's opinions on adoption? More altruistic or just as selfish?
Re: Reasons why you do not want to have kids?
Again what's missing here is the understanding that whether you have kids or not, these beings will be born into samsara based on their own kamma. So if I don't have kids, a being will be born into samsara, if I have kids, that being will still be born into samsara, but with the possibility to encounter the Dhamma (based on that being's kamma). In such a case you are providing conditions for escape - though again - much is dependent on that beings kamma.Mukunda wrote:Sustaining society is sustaining samsara. If one's focus is sustaining samsara, how does one escape from it?TMingyur wrote:To sustain society and its welfare - just to mention an example aspect of focusing on others in the context of one's own life.
-M
Re: Reasons why you do not want to have kids?
I understand that regardless of my decision to have children or not, beings will be born. That doesn't mean I have to participate in it, nor does it mean participating is beneficial. And as I see it, thinking that by having children I am providing an avenue for beings to escape samsara is egotistical, delusional rationalization covering a more selfish desire, namely the desire to continue through my offspringmeindzai wrote:Again what's missing here is the understanding that whether you have kids or not, these beings will be born into samsara based on their own kamma. So if I don't have kids, a being will be born into samsara, if I have kids, that being will still be born into samsara, but with the possibility to encounter the Dhamma (based on that being's kamma). In such a case you are providing conditions for escape - though again - much is dependent on that beings kamma.Mukunda wrote:Sustaining society is sustaining samsara. If one's focus is sustaining samsara, how does one escape from it?TMingyur wrote:To sustain society and its welfare - just to mention an example aspect of focusing on others in the context of one's own life.
Last edited by Mukunda on Mon Mar 15, 2010 8:02 pm, edited 1 time in total.
Re: Reasons why you do not want to have kids?
I think people are missing something about reality versus selfish intentions.
What I mean is that, people might have some intention based on ignorance, that they want to have kids, and go ahead with it. It seems people here are condemning that sort of behavior at least some. But the Buddha even okayed this kind of behavior, in some cases, when its in relation to the dhamma: the person who overcomes conceit by conceit, and overcomes craving by craving.
Some people take up the dhamma because of conceit and craving, and over time it just wears out the conceit and tires the craving...
Parenting, while I'm no parent, I imagine could be similar... One might become a parent out of craving. It might not be the same as the dream to become an arahant, but it could still cause a lot of humility and patience over time I would think.
One thing I've come to learn is that while quality of intention is very important, especially as it is a khammic factor, it doesn't seem to always correspond, at least at the perceptible level, with the actuality. For instance you could be thrilled to do something, then when you get around to it... it's not such hot stuff. That's a kind of disenchantment, which the Buddha praised. That could happen with having kids, I imagine. Of course, you're then stuck with them for another 10 or 20 years, at least, but that's the way it is with dhamma practice...
So while I would be mortified if, like in those movies and spoofs, an angel whisked me away to see my future, and said, "that's you," showing me 25 years from now sitting at the sideline of my kid's soccer game, that's the kind of mortification that might help get you out of samsara... bleak... and funny...
What I mean is that, people might have some intention based on ignorance, that they want to have kids, and go ahead with it. It seems people here are condemning that sort of behavior at least some. But the Buddha even okayed this kind of behavior, in some cases, when its in relation to the dhamma: the person who overcomes conceit by conceit, and overcomes craving by craving.
Some people take up the dhamma because of conceit and craving, and over time it just wears out the conceit and tires the craving...
Parenting, while I'm no parent, I imagine could be similar... One might become a parent out of craving. It might not be the same as the dream to become an arahant, but it could still cause a lot of humility and patience over time I would think.
One thing I've come to learn is that while quality of intention is very important, especially as it is a khammic factor, it doesn't seem to always correspond, at least at the perceptible level, with the actuality. For instance you could be thrilled to do something, then when you get around to it... it's not such hot stuff. That's a kind of disenchantment, which the Buddha praised. That could happen with having kids, I imagine. Of course, you're then stuck with them for another 10 or 20 years, at least, but that's the way it is with dhamma practice...
So while I would be mortified if, like in those movies and spoofs, an angel whisked me away to see my future, and said, "that's you," showing me 25 years from now sitting at the sideline of my kid's soccer game, that's the kind of mortification that might help get you out of samsara... bleak... and funny...
Re: Reasons why you do not want to have kids?
You don't seem particularly open to other interpretations.Mukunda wrote:
I understand that regardless of my decision to have children or not, beings will be born. That doesn't mean I have to participate in it, nor does it mean participating is beneficial. And as I see it, thinking that by having children I am providing an avenue for beings to escape samsara is egotistical, delusional rationalization covering a more selfish desire, namely the desire to continue through my offspring
-M
Re: Reasons why you do not want to have kids?
Hi M
I've certainly seen some wonderful examples of selfless acts of adoption. However, as recent events have shown us, the ugly side of adoption all too easily grabs the media spotlight.
Kind regards
Ben
I think it depends...meindzai wrote:Just curious - what are people's opinions on adoption? More altruistic or just as selfish?
-M
I've certainly seen some wonderful examples of selfless acts of adoption. However, as recent events have shown us, the ugly side of adoption all too easily grabs the media spotlight.
Kind regards
Ben
“No lists of things to be done. The day providential to itself. The hour. There is no later. This is later. All things of grace and beauty such that one holds them to one's heart have a common provenance in pain. Their birth in grief and ashes.”
- Cormac McCarthy, The Road
Learn this from the waters:
in mountain clefts and chasms,
loud gush the streamlets,
but great rivers flow silently.
- Sutta Nipata 3.725
Compassionate Hands Foundation (Buddhist aid in Myanmar) • Buddhist Global Relief • UNHCR
e: [email protected]..
- Cormac McCarthy, The Road
Learn this from the waters:
in mountain clefts and chasms,
loud gush the streamlets,
but great rivers flow silently.
- Sutta Nipata 3.725
Compassionate Hands Foundation (Buddhist aid in Myanmar) • Buddhist Global Relief • UNHCR
e: [email protected]..
Re: Reasons why you do not want to have kids?
Certainly not interpretations based in self delusion.meindzai wrote:You don't seem particularly open to other interpretations.Mukunda wrote:
I understand that regardless of my decision to have children or not, beings will be born. That doesn't mean I have to participate in it, nor does it mean participating is beneficial. And as I see it, thinking that by having children I am providing an avenue for beings to escape samsara is egotistical, delusional rationalization covering a more selfish desire, namely the desire to continue through my offspring
-M
Re: Reasons why you do not want to have kids?
To cherish them, not to create them is the greatest blessing.bodom wrote:To support mother and father, to cherish wife and children, and to be engaged in peaceful occupation — this is the greatest blessing. - Snp 2.4
Re: Reasons why you do not want to have kids?
Just as "hate is not dispelled by hate", wars are not ended by creating more combatants.tiltbillings wrote:I think we should have as many as possible to raise little warriors for the Buddha's cause. It is war out there.Mukunda wrote:How come no one asks "Why DO you want to have kids?"
Re: Reasons why you do not want to have kids?
My mistake. I wasn't aware you were completely free of self delusion.Mukunda wrote:Certainly not interpretations based in self delusion.meindzai wrote:You don't seem particularly open to other interpretations.Mukunda wrote:
I understand that regardless of my decision to have children or not, beings will be born. That doesn't mean I have to participate in it, nor does it mean participating is beneficial. And as I see it, thinking that by having children I am providing an avenue for beings to escape samsara is egotistical, delusional rationalization covering a more selfish desire, namely the desire to continue through my offspring
-M
-M
Re: Reasons why you do not want to have kids?
meindzai wrote:Again what's missing here is the understanding that whether you have kids or not, these beings will be born into samsara based on their own kamma.
I already tried to point out that the kamma of other beings is not our business.
If you have kids, a being will be born into samsara, based on the being's kamma and this wouldn't be your business.meindzai wrote:So if I don't have kids, a being will be born into samsara, if I have kids, that being will still be born into samsara, but with the possibility to encounter the Dhamma (based on that being's kamma).
If you don't have kids, a being will be born into samsara, based on the being's kamma and this wouldn't be your business either. In both cases there would probably be the posibility to encounter the Dhamma, based on that being's kamma, which still wouldn't be your business.
I think one should always ask himself: "Will this action by body, speech and/or mind, create more suffering?"
If the answer is "yes", one shouldn't do it and I don't think that anyone here will seriously tell me that birth won't create suffering. The first noble truth says "birth is suffering" how can someone seriously consider to have kids, that is to say to undertake (volitional) actions which will lead to birth, as right action?
It is not my intention to offend anyone. From my POV things just present themselves this way.
Probably there are unimaginable many circumstances which finally will lead to another birth and in general there's absolutely no problem in having kids but IMHO to have sex with the intention to have kids, I mean the volitional act of making kids itself isn't right action.
best wishes, acinteyyo
Thag 1.20. Ajita - I do not fear death; nor do I long for life. I’ll lay down this body, aware and mindful.