Interesting. Never thought of this before.That his name was 'Colonel Karuna' meaning 'compassion' is ironic considering his actions but it cannot be denied he was probably the biggest single factor in ending the bloodshed. So perhaps compassion or karuna of some form did win out in the end.
Can a Buddhist become a soldier?
Re: Can a Buddhist become a soldier?
“As the lamp consumes oil, the path realises Nibbana”
Re: Can a Buddhist become a soldier?
I spoke for quite some time with Sitagu Sayadaw's English biographer, Bhikkhu Cintita, about this issue of Burmese Buddhists serving the military.
https://insightmyanmar.org/complete-sho ... e-buddhism
https://insightmyanmar.org/complete-sho ... e-buddhism
Re: Can a Buddhist become a soldier?
I don't remember what sutta it was, but I do remember reading one where the Buddha said something along the lines that the definition of a Buddhist was someone who had taken refuge in the Triple Gem, and a practicing Buddhist was one who practiced the Five Precepts. (This may not be exactly what he said, but what I recall was along those lines.)
Curiously, though soldier is not specifically mentioned in Right/Wrong Livelihood, a prohibition against making weapons is. So I have always taken this to mean that one should not work for the DOD, so I have always declined jobs requiring a Security Clearance, even though I'm pretty sure I could easily get one.
May all beings, in or out of the womb, be well, happy and peaceful.
Re: Can a Buddhist become a soldier?
You don't have to go that far. There're lots of diverse areas within DoD. As long as one involves in programs that work on defensive capabilities (reconnaissance, signal intelligence, electronic/radar defense, composite armour, etc...) instead of offensive, that should be fine.tharpa wrote: ↑Thu Apr 28, 2022 11:55 pm Curiously, though soldier is not specifically mentioned in Right/Wrong Livelihood, a prohibition against making weapons is. So I have always taken this to mean that one should not work for the DOD, so I have always declined jobs requiring a Security Clearance, even though I'm pretty sure I could easily get one.
Re: Can a Buddhist become a soldier?
That depends on what your religious leader is said to have said about "Noble Eightfold Path" in the context of lay folks and what he is said to have said in the context of following or resisting the directives of the head of a nation/state in case of a non-democratic regime or in the context of following or resisting the regulations in case of democratic nations/states.
Cleared. αδόξαστος.
- DNS
- Site Admin
- Posts: 17230
- Joined: Tue Dec 30, 2008 4:15 am
- Location: Las Vegas, Nevada, Estados Unidos de América
- Contact:
Re: Can a Buddhist become a soldier?
I don't think the Buddha specifically states that this is the definition but it's kind of implied and has become a common method for defining a Buddhist as one who takes refuge in the triple gem. One can be a Buddhist, but still violate precepts; it would make one a bad Buddhist, but still a Buddhist (see: No true Scotsman).tharpa wrote: ↑Thu Apr 28, 2022 11:55 pm I don't remember what sutta it was, but I do remember reading one where the Buddha said something along the lines that the definition of a Buddhist was someone who had taken refuge in the Triple Gem, and a practicing Buddhist was one who practiced the Five Precepts. (This may not be exactly what he said, but what I recall was along those lines.)
In the Suttas, there is General Siha (who was a general in the military) but still attained stream-entry.
And then there is Samyutta Nikaya 42.3 which states that soldiers go to lower realms.
The seeming contradiction could be that perhaps General Siha did not personally kill anyone on the battlefield.
Re: Can a Buddhist become a soldier?
Here is the sutta in question:DNS wrote: ↑Fri Apr 29, 2022 10:20 pmI don't think the Buddha specifically states that this is the definition but it's kind of implied and has become a common method for defining a Buddhist as one who takes refuge in the triple gem. One can be a Buddhist, but still violate precepts; it would make one a bad Buddhist, but still a Buddhist (see: No true Scotsman).tharpa wrote: ↑Thu Apr 28, 2022 11:55 pm I don't remember what sutta it was, but I do remember reading one where the Buddha said something along the lines that the definition of a Buddhist was someone who had taken refuge in the Triple Gem, and a practicing Buddhist was one who practiced the Five Precepts. (This may not be exactly what he said, but what I recall was along those lines.)
Mahānāma Sutta (AN 8.25) wrote: “In what way, Bhante, is one a lay follower?”
“When, Mahānāma, one has gone for refuge to the Buddha, the Dhamma, and the Saṅgha, in that way one is a lay follower.”
“In what way, Bhante, is a lay follower virtuous?”
“When, Mahānāma, a lay follower abstains from the destruction of life, from taking what is not given, from sexual misconduct, from false speech, and from liquor, wine, and intoxicants, the basis for heedlessness, in that way a lay follower is virtuous.”
- DNS
- Site Admin
- Posts: 17230
- Joined: Tue Dec 30, 2008 4:15 am
- Location: Las Vegas, Nevada, Estados Unidos de América
- Contact:
Re: Can a Buddhist become a soldier?
Good find, good suttas.
Re: Can a Buddhist become a soldier?
Having said that I won't become a buddhist because buddhist doctrine is far from taking a position in favour of democratic values.SteRo wrote: ↑Fri Apr 29, 2022 6:27 pmThat depends on what your religious leader is said to have said about "Noble Eightfold Path" in the context of lay folks and what he is said to have said in the context of following or resisting the directives of the head of a nation/state in case of a non-democratic regime or in the context of following or resisting the regulations in case of democratic nations/states.
Cleared. αδόξαστος.
Re: Can a Buddhist become a soldier?
Which is a kind of ridiculous verbal expression because there aren't any values in the first place. So? After all I seem to believe in the superiority of the culture that has formed my self. Thus a buddhist believer cannot become a soldier but a non-believer can become a soldier of any kind of regime.
Cleared. αδόξαστος.
Re: Can a Buddhist become a soldier?
Thus a Buddhist practitioner does not become a soldier. FTFY
May all beings, in or out of the womb, be well, happy and peaceful.